Annals of Open Science · open access for all disciplines Create account

Home › Publish › Peer review process

Peer review process

Every research submission is assessed by at least two independent experts, and the reports are published with the article.

Stages

  1. Screening. Automated checks and an editorial triage for scope, completeness and ethics.
  2. Review. At least two reviewers with relevant expertise, plus a statistics or data editor for Research Articles. Reviewers accept or decline within a few days and are asked to return reports in 14 days.
  3. Decision. The handling editor decides on the reports and the manuscript. Editors do not handle papers they authored or have a conflict with.
  4. Revision. Authors respond point by point. Further rounds follow when needed.
  5. Integrity audit. After acceptance, raw data, figures, statistics, references and text are checked. A named integrity editor signs off.

Open reports

Decision letters and reviewer reports are published alongside the article. Reviewers may be named or anonymous; their choice is recorded when they accept the invitation.

Conflicts of interest and confidentiality

Reviewers and editors declare competing interests before accepting. Manuscripts are confidential. Reviewers must not upload manuscripts to public AI tools.

Appeals

Authors may appeal one rejection. A different editor reviews the appeal.

Reviewers are paid

Reviewers receive a payment for each completed review or may take a credit toward their own publication fee. Payment never depends on the recommendation or the outcome. See Information for reviewers.